ENGL 200-010
MWF 905-955
MEM 124

Kainoa Harbottle
kharbot@udel.edu
Office: MEM 213
Office Hourse:
M, W 1100-1200
and by appointment

 

 

 

 

Essays

Mini Essay: What is Literature?

In two pages or less, define what literature is. What boundaries delineate where literature begins and “trashy” popular culture end? How do you know literature when you see it? How does your definition of literature match up with other college students? Do you think your definition gels with the definition of the general population?

Be sure to distinguish between what you think it is and how you feel other people respond to it (so, yes, you’ll probably have to use first person—a few times).

If you need to turn to a dictionary to figure this out, please use the OED available through the library database.

Essay 1: Poetry

Please select one of the following topics for your poetry essay. You must use at least one scholarly source besides the text of the poem for the paper. Following the topics you will find some helpful directions to get you off to a good start.

1) Analyze the use of a formal characteristic (rhyme, meter, metaphor, structure), image, or word that appears in two assigned poems from two different authors. Does this particular aspect reveal a relationship between the two poems? Does it suggest a point of contention between the two poems? Does it reveal a state of ambiguity between them?

2) While examining the use of a particular formal characteristic, image, or word in any poem on our schedule page, discuss how a specific part of the poem affects the whole piece in relation to ambiguity (remember the identical roads from Frost’s “The Road Not Taken”?). How does this particular moment disrupt the coherence of the overall poem (i.e. take away from what the poem seems to be saying)? Is this moment an intentional decision: there to generate a paradox the reader must negotiate? Or does this sequence reveal a hidden assumption, concern, or confusion on the part of the author that cannot be resolved by the reader with the rest of the text?

3) Perform a biographical reading of one (or a few) poem(s) from a single author we have read. How has his or her life experiences carried over into his or her works? For example, how does the knowledge that Plath’s father was a beekeeper and a professor rather than a Fascist and a Nazi affect the interpretation of her poetry? How did Dickinson’s life as a recluse affect the content of her poetry? How was Hughes's personal experiences in the African-American community (with his more conservative inclinations) manifest in his writing? A good starting point for researching author’s biographies is at the Literature Research Center, which you can access through the library databases.

4) Explore a larger theme (like race, class, gender, sexuality, Eros, Thanotos, violence—please pick only ONE) in one or two of the poems on the syllabus. How does the art interact with this particular ideology? Does it promote or disintegrate it? Does it reveal conflicting attitudes inherent within the theme itself? What does the poet want the reader to conclude about his or her time period? Or about the politics of poetry—what poetry can or cannot do? [e.g. What does Dickinson’s “My life had stood—” reveal about the nature of patriarchy in her society? What does Kumin’s “Woodchucks” reveal about modern humanity’s violent tendencies?]

5) Expand on one of your blogs, taking your original work as a starting point to jump off and explore the question in greater detail or come up with a better question. You must e-mail me by September 17th if you plan to do this, since I will require some specific development from the original text for this assignment.

I’m looking for three to five pages of double spaced, 12 point Times New Roman font (as usual).  One inch margins all the way around, please.  Include your name, my name, the class, and the date in the upper left hand corner of the first page.  Every following page should have your last name and the page number in the upper right hand corner.  Remember to include a Works Cited page at the very end (to practice your MLA format as well as get in the habit of always informing your reader of your sources).

Remember that you have to use at least one “scholarly” outside source. By scholarly, I mean publications refereed by scholars, and typically published through university presses or presses invested in scholarly pursuits. Notice that the word scholarly was specifically chosen to direct you away from non-scholarly (though still vetted) online sources (Wikipedia) and towards the gigantic den of evil (Morris Library). A few places to check for scholarly sources: 1) Run a keyword search on DELCAT regarding your topic and see what pops up. Books that look like collections of essays (such as Critical Essays on Emily Dickinson) might be a nice general place to start. 2) Browse the stacks around works on your author and see if any titles jump out at you. 3) On the University of Delaware Library’s Databases in the Arts and Humanities section, check out Literature Online, Literature Research Center, and MLA International Bibliography. These places will give you citations about your topic which you can then find (or try to find) in our library. Remember it’s always better to start with a few sources rather than just one--that way if one does not pan out, you have others to fall back on. 5) Sigh. Check out Wikipedia: No, do not use the entry itself. IF YOU SITE WIKIPEDIA AS A SOURCE, I WILL THROW YOUR PAPER IN THE TRASH. Instead, use Wikipedia for what it’s really good for: stealing other people’s sources. Look at the bottom of the entry where sources are usually listed. Check these out. If they take you to another online source whose authorship, you cannot be certain of (iluvsylviaplath.com), do not use that source. If they direct you to some specific published sources, go crazy in DELCAT and see if you can find it.

Please read through the MLA Citation and Plagiarism  page for Works Cited page guidelines as well as a general discussion as to how to avoid any accidental plagiarism.  Also checkout the online edition of the Bedford Handbook for general citation information as well as a sample paper.

You should also look at the Writer's Checklist on my Writing site.  This will give you clues as to how to go about putting the paper together, what I expect from a good paper, and what my pet peeves are about grading papers (i.e. how to avoid upsetting me for no good reason).

Lastly, checkout the descriptions I give of my own Grading Standards, so that you know what I'm looking for when I put grades on your papers.

Essay Due: Monday, 27 September 2007

Essay 2: Short Story

Please select one of the following topics for your short story essay. You must integrate at least one scholarly source into your argument. Following the topics you will find a few directives that will guide you towards generating a better paper.

1) Argue the significance of an object or symbol from one of the stories listed on the syllabus. In what way does that symbol affect the lives of the various characters or the events of the narrative? What does it represent—and to whom? Does it generate conflict or help lead to a resolution?

2) Analyze any two characters from two of the stories we read this semester in conjunction with one of the following themes: family, class, sexuality, race, or gender and gender roles. [Feel free to pick a different theme, but clear it with me first.]

3) How does a story’s setting affect its theme? Using one of the stories listed on the syllabus, show how a text’s setting influences a particular theme. How does the location's clarity or ambiguity affect the meaning of the story? Does it make the meaning more poignant or does it detract from the story’s overall purpose?

4) Choose your own adventure. E-mail me a topic you're interested in working on; please do so by Oct 15th if you, since I will require some specific development and focus for this assignment.

Again, I'm asking for three to five pages of double spaced, 12 point Times New Roman font.  One inch margins all the way around, please.  Include your name, my name, the class, and the date in the upper left hand corner of the first page.  Every following page should have your last name and the page number in the upper right hand corner.  Remember to include a Works Cited page at the very end (to practice your MLA format as well as get in the habit of always informing your reader of your sources).  And yes, you should cite the work you are quoting from (your primary text) as well as the outside source you use to back up your argument (secondary material).

Speaking of which, please remember that this should be a “scholarly” outside source. By scholarly, I mean publications refereed by scholars, and typically published through university presses or presses invested in scholarly pursuits. Notice that the word scholarly was specifically chosen to direct you away from non-scholarly (though still vetted) online sources (Wikipedia) and towards the cavernous repository of darkness (Morris Library). Bottom line--it's hard to go wrong when you use a book on the topic. The internet opens a can of worms before you even get a word on the page.

The only real sources I will direct you to that Mr. Computer can help you with is those located in DELCAT or on the University of Delaware Library’s Databases in the Arts and Humanities section. Look to Literature Online, Literature Research Center, and MLA International Bibliography (especially the Literature Research Center). The LRC will provide you with vetted biographies and textual analysis of our works. The other places will give you citations about your topic which you can then find (or try to find) in our library.

Before you begin the paper refresh your memory with my MLA Citation and Plagiarism page for Works Cited page guidelines as well as a general discussion as to how to avoid any accidental plagiarism.  Also checkout the online edition of the Bedford Handbook for general citation information as well as a sample paper.

It would have helped a number of you to look at my Writer's Checklist on the Writing site for the first paper.  Do not neglect this for this assignment.

The last thing to fill you with dread should be my Grading Standards.

Essay Due: Monday, 22 October 2007

Essay 3: Drama

Please select one of the questions below for your drama essay. You must integrate at least one scholarly source into your argument. Following the topics you will find a few suggestions that will help you to develop your paper.

1) Provide a concise definition for the genre of comedy in drama (and notice that this is asking for a very precise concept of comedy—as it pertains to plays). Looking at both of the plays we have read this semester, show how your definition manifests itself in the works. Does comedy stem from language play? From actions that are or are not represented in the text? How important is the reader’s imagination to the effectiveness of comedy?

2) Both of these plays are about manipulation and deception in regards to love. Sorting through these deceptions makes up a key part of the structural climax in Taming and Importance. Does love excuse deception, as Wilde’s characters (ironically) suggest? Looking at specific characters or scenes from both of the plays, discuss whether or not deception is the most expedient way to attain one’s desires, or if it ultimately threatens disappointment.

3) Gender and relationships are probably the most important thematic of the comedies we have read. Choose a character or couple from both of the plays, and examine how drama has changed its representation of gender or romance, if at all, in the 300 years between our authors. Are things getting better for men, women, or relationships, or is the idea of progress on any of these fronts just an illusion?

4) Posit your own topic focusing on where you see these two works interacting (please e-mail me by the 13th if you plan to do this, since I require a certain amount of extra work from this assignment).

As usual, I wish to see three to five pages that are double spaced and in 12 point Times New Roman font.  One inch margins all the way around, or don't bother turning it in.  Include your name, my name, the class, and the date in the upper left hand corner of the first page.  Every following page should have your last name and the page number in the upper right hand corner.  Remember to include a Works Cited page at the very end.  And, naturally, you should cite the works you are quoting from (your primary texts) as well as the outside source you use to back up your argument (secondary material). If you did not purchase the books, you will have to cite your quotations by act, scene and (if you have it) line numbers.

Remember that this should be a “scholarly” outside source. By scholarly, I mean publications refereed by scholars, and typically published through university presses or presses invested in scholarly pursuits. Notice that the word scholarly was specifically chosen to direct you away from non-scholarly (though still vetted) online sources (Wikipedia) and towards the monumental chamber of confusion (Morris Library). Bottom line--it's hard to go wrong when you use a book on the topic. The internet opens a can of worms before you even get a word on the page. And then what do you have but a wormy paper. Ick.

The best sources for you are those located in DELCAT or on the University of Delaware Library’s Databases in the Arts and Humanities section. In the databases, check out Literature Online, Literature Research Center, and MLA International Bibliography (especially the Literature Research Center). The LRC will provide you with vetted biographies and textual analysis of our works, as well as helpful definitions for specific terms. The other places will give you citations about your topic which you can then find (or try to find) in our library.

Before you begin the paper, refresh your memory with my MLA Citation and Plagiarism page for Works Cited page guidelines as well as a general discussion as to how to avoid any accidental plagiarism.  Also peruse the online edition of the Bedford Handbook for general citation information as well as a sample paper.

Do not forget my Writer's Checklist on the Writing site.  I never do.

One last thing to leave you full of fear and loathing is my Grading Standards.

Essay Due: Monday, 19 November 2007

Essay 4: Film

Please select one of the questions below for your drama essay. You must integrate at least one scholarly source into your argument. Following the topics, you will find the usual links meant to encourage and/or fill you with self-doubt.

1) Both Girl, Interrupted (GI) and Fight Club (FC) are incredibly dynamic in terms of their filmic properties. They use the medium as a way to express the themes of the given film. How does the form of the film--in terms of shot composition, camera techniques, or editing—speak to its topics? Looking at both movies, discuss how a particular theme is evidenced by the form of the film itself.

2) The idea of gender identity plays an important role in both GI and FG, either implicitly or explicitly. What do these films reveal about gender and the assumptions about femininity and masculinity during the historical period they both depict? Consider inverting the more obvious associations of femininity with GI and masculinity with FC. How do the films represent the opposite gender of their main characters, and what assumptions do the films make about these simplified but still poignant gender roles?

3) In terms of their central problems, both films focus on the idea of finding something that most likely does not exist: Susanna Kaysen’s insanity in GI and a non-capitalist utopia in FC. How do these films go about representing these absences, and are they ever found?

4) Depression and escapism are interrelated themes in both movies. How do GI and FG represent this cluster of concepts? Do the films suggest solutions to the situations or do they imply that most people are incapable of change?

5) Suggest your own topic of your own devising that attempts to show how these films dovetail. Please e-mail me by the 13th if you intend to do this, since I want to make sure you are just not being nutty.

Yet again, I desire three to five pages, double spaced and in 12 point Times New Roman font.  One inch margins all the way around, or just set the thing on fire.  Include your name, my name, the class, and the date in the upper left hand corner of the first page.  Every following page should have your last name and the page number in the upper right hand corner.  Remember to include a Works Cited page at the very end.  And, yes, you should cite the works you are quoting from and the outside source you use to back up your argument.

Before you begin the paper, please stare at my MLA Citation and Plagiarism page for Works Cited page guidelines as well as a general discussion as to how to avoid any accidental plagiarism.  Also peruse the online edition of the Bedford Handbook for general citation information as well as a sample paper, especially since this is a film rather than a text..

Please peruse my Writer's Checklist on the Writing site as well as my Grading Standards.

Essay Due: Wednesday, 5 December 2007

Required Assignments

Blogs: Blogging assignments will be a key part of your written work in the class. You will be given a question or a series of questions for some of the Thursday (and one Tuesday) readings. The day before class you must publish a blog in response to the question or questions on your blogging page by 5pm. I will check the blogs weekly to evaluate them.

The blogs will be graded on the basis of your interaction with the question—how much thought are you evidencing, how sophisticated are you being? I will give you either a check ++, a check +, check, or check- based on your work. A check++ is very rare—it means that you have created a flawless masterpiece. A check+ means that you are above average yet not quite perfect. A check means that you are obviously engaged with the question and are doing an adequate job. A check- means that you are slipping beneath the level of work I expect from you. Unacceptable work will receive a 0. At the end of the semester, I will then translate your collection of checks into a point total out of 100 (depending on the number of blogs we do this semester). The blog assignments are a very easy way to maintain a good grade in the class. Do them diligently and there should not be a problem.

When writing your blog, please be sure to follow both of the following steps, numbering them clearly in your entry. You do not need to include these instructions (I will remember them).

1. Summarize your general experience with the reading (How did it make you feel? Did you agree or disagree with the argument? Did it resonate with anything in your personal life? Was it difficult or easy to read and why?). [4 meaty but concise sentences]

2. The last section of the Blog will vary from week to week, but it usually will be a specific question or assignment regarding the text. [at least a paragraph—10-12 meaty but concise sentences]

Essays 1, 2, 3, & 4: Each of these essays will be a 3-5 page paper focusing on a specific question directly tied to our readings and discussions. The goal of each of these essays will be to push your interpretation of the texts beyond the scope of what was covered in class and thereby reveal your own interaction with the issues at hand. These essays must follow the expectation guidelines for written work and conform to the general writing guidelines provided online. Some research in the library will be expected of you for some of the assignments.

Revision Policy: Your first two primary assignments may be revised within two weeks of being returned for additional point consideration. Your total may be raised a maximum of only one grade (for example, from a C- to a B-). No late assignments may be revised. Please understand that a revision is not merely correcting spelling and grammar errors or adding a few sentences—that is a waste of all our times. To revise (literally re-vision, to see anew) a paper is to begin from scratch, reassessing the question to create a polished argument. Anyone interested in revising an assignment must have a conference with me in order for the revision to be accepted. All revisions must also include the original, graded draft. Work that I consider to be substandard will not be eligible for revisions at my discretion—this is to prevent you from taking advantage of my generosity for allowing revisions.

Quizzes: I reserve the right to quiz you on your daily reading assignments. The number of questions will vary for each day—sometimes as few as 3 or 4 questions, sometimes as many as 10. Although these quizzes may seem a small part of the class (five points here, ten points there), they do add up and affect your grade in the long run.

In-Class Writing: In addition to quizzes, I also reserve the right to ask you to perform a writing exercise on any given day. These exercises will vary—sometimes they will be as relaxed as freewriting on a theme or a question. Sometimes they will require you to apply critical terms to a specific textual instance. These assignments will test your ability to think, process, and respond clearly and effectively in an “on the spot” situation. I may collect these at any time or ask you to hand them in with other secondary or primary assignments.